I wrote a quick response at the request of a friend, please forgive minor errors as I did this over lunch
“I’m good, God loves me” **See first reply
Point One,
Let’s start with the definition of Religion.
Definition two and four in the Webster’s are the relevant
ones:
“a personal set or
institutionalized system of religious attitudes, beliefs, and practices”
“a cause, principle, or system
of beliefs held to with ardor and faith”
Christianity easily fits into either of these definitions,
thus Christianity is a religion.
The definition of Gospel:
“the
message concerning Christ, the kingdom of God, and Salvation.
Christianity is a group or
fellowship of people following the message/gospel, thus Christianity itself
cannot be gospel.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Point Two,
I’m going to compare a couple of statements that were
presented in the image.
Religion:
“If I obey I am accepted”
Gospel:
“I’m
accepted so I obey”
The second is a clever rewording of the first and implies a
different meaning, namely that “I was given something so I obey” rather than “
I obey so that I can get something”
The argument here is that Jesus paid the price for our
salvation (heaven) already and that is our gift, we simply need to accept it
(obey).
A parallel to this would be a parent buying their child a
gift (it’s bought with money as our entry into heaven is by blood) but the
child cannot yet have the gift (heaven). They must be good until Christmas (death)
or they won’t receive the gift.
Using this example we can decipher the second statement
(presented in the image) and see that in fact we are obeying to receive because we will not receive if we do not obey. Keep in mind that believing in and accepting christ into your heart is an action.
“I obey, I receive”
“I obey, I’m
Accepted”
“ I’m accepted so I obey”
These all echo the same meaning.
Religion:
“Focus:
What I do or don’t do”
Gospel:
“Focus: What
Jesus did”
The focus in Christianity is actually on what the individual
does, accepting Christ and being repentant is something you are required to do
if you wish to avoid the agony of hell. Without this acceptance and the
subsequent devotion required not to stray too far, you cannot remain in the
bubble of forgiveness and go to heaven. So in reality Christianity (despite
it’s assertions to the contrary) is a religion based on actions, just a much
smaller set of actions.
If in truth the faith were about what Jesus did, then there
would be no required actions to take advantage of his “gift”. After all a gift
is something given for nothing.
To take this one step further,
If a person
is mentally deranged enough to not believe their family exists what happens? It
many cases the family will try to make the person aware of them, provide for
the mentally ill one and bring them gifts. Is a human more compassionate than
god? Is god really so petty as to forget those who can’t see his hand?
Alright, lunch break over… haha, let me know what you think.
Comment Away!
"A parallel to this would be a parent buying their child a gift (it’s bought with money as our entry into heaven is by blood) but the child cannot yet have the gift (heaven). They must be good until Christmas (death) or they won’t receive the gift."
ReplyDeleteThis is not a parallel. Please study for yourself the doctrine of regeneration.
also, we don't have to be good until death in order to be saved. salvation is by faith alone, in Christ alone, by grace alone. All Christians continue to sin in this life, but they are assured their salvation through what is called the doctrine of justification. Please study that for yourself as well.
lastly, you seem to think that making the distinction between "i obey so God loves me" and "God loves me so I obey" is just "clever rewording of the same thing." To me, this is the worst logical conclusion. It's actually not logical at all. I suggest you study logical argumentation as well. (you can look that stuff up on wikipedia. Quick example of this fallacy in logic: "I ate a burger so I would not be hungry anymore." is that the same as saying "I am not hungry so I ate a burger."? Of course not.
So that's your homework. To me, you don't seem to understand even the basics of Christian theology and are not fit to make any intelligent criticisms of it. So please, for your own good, and for the good of your unknowing readers, study deeply that which you wish to refute. My suggestion? Wayne Grudem's book called "Systematic Theology" is a great resource for the topics you are questioning.
start with the doctrines of regeneration and justification.
Regeneration presents no new information to make the example inaccurate, as one can still fall from this "regenerated state" via denying one/all of the trinity or losing faith.
ReplyDeleteFaith is based on the action of believing and can be lost when one stops believing, to go to heaven one must believe (be good) until death. Thus one must "be good" until death or suffer the consequences.
I will agree that “I’m good, God loves me” does not belong in that short list, however I encourage you to address the parallels in the other quotes. (Updated post)
I appreciate the book suggestions btw.
the doctrine of regeneration does not include the possibility of "falling" from the regenerated state. Once one's heart is regenerated, it cannot be un-regenerated. It only happens once, it cannot be undone. Biblically, if someone denies or "loses" faith in Christ, it means they were never actually regenerated in the first place(Hebrews 6 states that it is impossible to be saved, then lose salvation, and then be saved again). Once saved, always saved--no matter if you are "good" or not. In fact, if it were true that we had to be good until death NO ONE would make it. Faith in Christ justifies us before God (we are seen as if we are without sin), but this life is all about sanctification (being transformed by God in a process whereby one is made more and more like Jesus).
ReplyDeleteAgain, you don't seem to understand the basics of Christian theology. Get Wayne Grudem's book, it will help you immensely.
Look up the doctrines of justification and sanctification. This will hopefully help you understand that salvation is by faith alone, in Christ alone, by grace alone.
Thanks for your peaceful interaction with me :)